Statutory Audit of Current Investments in Indian Companies [Company Law]

PDFPrint

Introduction

Current Investments are classified under current assets in the balance sheet and are expected to be liquidated or utilized within a short time frame, generally 12 months or within the operating cycle, whichever is longer. These investments can include shares, bonds, mutual funds, treasury bills, or other marketable securities. Their transient nature and potential financial significance make auditing Current Investments an essential part of the statutory audit process.

This detailed guide outlines the statutory audit procedures for Current Investments under Indian company laws, including a full legal framework, addressing common queries, and providing practical examples for better understanding.

Objectives of Auditing Current Investments

1. Verification of Existence and Ownership: Ensure the investments are real and belong to the entity.
2. Accuracy in Valuation: Confirm investments are valued as per applicable accounting standards.
3. Classification and Disclosure: Verify the proper classification of investments as “Current” and check for compliance with disclosure norms.
4. Regulatory Compliance: Assess compliance with the Companies Act, Income Tax Act, and SEBI guidelines.
5. Mitigation of Misstatements: Detect potential errors, frauds, or irregularities.

Audit Methodology

1. Preliminary Planning

• Understanding Business Context: Review the nature of investments held and their alignment with the company’s operational goals.
• Review of Investment Policy: Examine the entity’s policy on investments, including approval procedures, risk assessments, and return expectations.

2. Substantive Audit Procedures

Existence and Ownership

• Obtain a detailed schedule of Current Investments.
• Verify investments with physical certificates, Demat account statements, or confirmations from depositories or custodians.
• Match recorded entries with purchase agreements, broker notes, or bank statements.

Valuation

• Review the accounting treatment under AS 13 (Accounting for Investments).
• Verify the valuation of investments at cost or fair value (whichever is lower).
• Check for provision recognition for any diminution in value and assess whether it is temporary or permanent.

Recording and Classification

• Ensure proper classification of investments into “Current” based on their maturity or intended holding period.
• Cross-check balances with trial balances and ledgers.

Compliance Testing

• Verify compliance with Section 186 of the Companies Act regarding investment limits and approvals.
• Check for adherence to SEBI regulations, particularly for listed companies.

Disclosures

• Ensure disclosures in the notes to accounts cover all relevant details, including valuation basis, nature, and movements during the year.

3. Analytical Procedures

• Perform ratio analysis to assess the proportionality of investments to total assets or current assets.
• Compare yields or returns on investments with industry benchmarks.

4. Testing Controls

• Evaluate internal controls for investment decisions, recording, and monitoring.
• Test the operational effectiveness of controls by sampling transactions.

5. Related Party Transactions

• Examine transactions involving related parties for transparency and compliance with legal and disclosure requirements.

6. Reclassification Testing

• Verify that long-term investments are not incorrectly classified as current investments to inflate liquidity ratios.

Legal Framework

Companies Act, 2013

1. Section 128 (Books of Account):
   • Mandates accurate records of investment transactions, including details of purchase, valuation, and sale.
2. Section 129 (Financial Statements):
   • Requires that investments are fairly presented in financial statements following applicable accounting standards.
3. Section 134 (Directors’ Responsibility Statement):
   • Obligates directors to ensure accurate reporting and compliance with accounting standards.
4. Section 186 (Loans and Investments):
   • Specifies limits on investments and requires board/shareholder approval for amounts exceeding thresholds.
5. Schedule III:
   • Provides guidelines for the presentation and disclosure of Current Investments, emphasizing clarity and completeness.

Accounting Standards (AS)

1. AS 13 – Accounting for Investments:
   • Current Investments must be valued at cost or fair value, whichever is lower.
   • Provisions for diminutions should be recognized in the income statement.
2. AS 2 – Valuation of Inventories:
   • Applicable for investments held as stock-in-trade, valued at cost or NRV, whichever is lower.

Income Tax Act, 1961

• Section 14A: Disallows expenses related to income exempt from tax, such as dividends.
• Interest income and capital gains must be reported per the provisions of the Act.

SEBI Regulations

• Mandates timely and transparent disclosures for listed companies.
• Requires compliance with SEBI (LODR) Regulations for material investment transactions.

ICAI Standards on Auditing (SAs)

• SA 500: Obtain sufficient audit evidence for verifying investments.
• SA 530: Use sampling techniques for testing large volumes of transactions.
• SA 580: Obtain written representations from management on valuation and disclosures.

Practical Examples

Example 1: Listed Equity Shares

• Scenario: ₹20 lakhs invested in equity shares of listed companies.
• Audit Approach:
  • Cross-check holdings with Demat statements.
  • Verify year-end valuation using stock exchange data.
• Insight: Lack of reconciliation could lead to overstatement of value.

Example 2: Liquid Mutual Funds

• Scenario: ₹30 lakhs parked in mutual funds for short-term liquidity.
• Audit Approach:
  • Obtain fund statements.
  • Verify NAV for valuation.
• Insight: Unrealized gains incorrectly classified as revenue can misstate profitability.

Example 3: Treasury Bills

• Scenario: ₹50 lakhs invested in government treasury bills.
• Audit Approach:
  • Validate transactions with broker notes and bank statements.
  • Check for amortized cost valuation.
• Insight: Errors in interest accrual could misrepresent short-term assets.

Example 4: Related Party Investments

• Scenario: ₹10 lakhs invested in an associate company’s bonds.
• Audit Approach:
  • Identify the transaction as a related party deal.
  • Verify board approval and compliance with Section 186.
• Insight: Non-compliance with disclosures can lead to regulatory penalties.

Example 5: Unquoted Shares

• Scenario: ₹5 lakhs invested in private equity shares.
• Audit Approach:
  • Review valuation reports from independent valuers.
  • Verify existence through share certificates.
• Insight: Misclassification as quoted shares impacts fair valuation.

Example 6: Dividend Income

• Scenario: Dividend of ₹2 lakhs earned from equity holdings.
• Audit Approach:
  • Cross-check receipts with bank statements.
  • Confirm timely recognition in income.
• Insight: Misstated income affects net profit calculations.

Example 7: Fraudulent Investments

• Scenario: Inflated investment value detected during audit.
• Audit Approach:
  • Trace each investment transaction back to source documents.
  • Compare with third-party confirmations.
• Insight: Weak internal controls can lead to misappropriation of funds.

Example 8: Investment Reclassification

• Scenario: Long-term investments reclassified as current to inflate liquidity.
• Audit Approach:
  • Compare classification with investment intent and holding period.
  • Flag deviations for management explanation.
• Insight: Misclassification distorts financial metrics.

Example 9: Fixed Deposits

• Scenario: ₹15 lakhs in short-term fixed deposits.
• Audit Approach:
  • Verify balances with bank confirmations.
  • Validate accrued interest recognition.
• Insight: Maturity dates must align with classification criteria.

Example 10: Investments in Debt Instruments

• Scenario: ₹25 lakhs in corporate bonds.
• Audit Approach:
  • Validate interest receivables and valuation.
  • Assess default risks using credit ratings.
• Insight: Ignoring credit risk leads to understated provisioning.

Conclusion

Auditing Current Investments requires a rigorous approach encompassing verification, valuation, compliance, and disclosure. Practical insights and a strong grasp of legal and regulatory frameworks equip auditors to ensure financial statements’ accuracy and integrity.

Author

CA Sourabh Kothari (C.A., B.Com)
He is currently working as Partner – Risk and Transaction advisory with a renowned firm in Jaipur having experience in Internal Audit, IFC Audit, Business consultancy, Due Diligence and Management consultancy.
E-mail: Sourabh.kothari@jainshrimal.in | LinkedIn: Sourabh Kothari

Connect with us on: LinkedIn, Telegram, Instagram, Facebook, Twitter and Youtube for regular Updates.

PDFPrint